Are Electric Cars Better for the Environment? mai-15-2024

The automotive industry is undergoing a seismic shift as electric vehicles (EVs) emerge as the frontrunners in sustainable transportation.

In this article we will deep-dive in the long-term environmental advantages of EVs over their fossil fuel counterparts. Despite initial concerns about emissions from battery manufacturing, studies show that EVs demonstrate superior environmental performance over the entire lifecycle when compared to traditional gasoline and diesel cars.

This revelation not only highlights the potential of EVs to mitigate climate change but also signals a fundamental transformation in the automotive industry towards greener and more sustainable practices.

Long-Term Environmental Impact

The German Institute for Energy and Environmental Research (IFEU) in Heidelberg conducted a study of 23 recent scientific publications to find out the magnitude of the differences in emissions between combustion cars and electric cars.

The study focused on the greenhouse gas emissions during the manufacturing of electric cars compared to gasoline and diesel cars.

The production of batteries for electric cars has long been a point of concern regarding environmental impact.

However, the study shows that despite the initial emissions during manufacturing, electric cars outperform in terms of being better for the environment on a long-term basis.

According to the study, an electric car with a 35-kilowatt-hour battery consumes 16 kilowatt-hours per 100 kilometers. In comparison, a gasoline car consumes 5.9 liters per 100 kilometers, and a diesel car consumes 4.7 liters per 100 kilometers.

Well-To-Wheel

In the article Well-to-wheels scenarios for 2050 carbon-neutral road transport in the EU published in Journal of Cleaner Production, March 2024, they highlight the substantial demand for electricity in road transport and the importance of production pathways of energy carriers in influencing well-to-wheel (WtW) energy consumption, which can be crucial in comparing the emissions impact of electric vehicles and fossil-fueled vehicles.

Well-to-Wheel refers to the total energy consumption and emissions associated with a vehicle’s fuel or energy source from the initial production stage (well) to the final consumption stage (wheel). It includes factors like energy losses during production, transportation, and actual vehicle usage.

Transforming the Automotive Landscape

Electric vehicles (EVs) are not just revolutionizing transportation; they are reshaping the entire automotive industry. With a growing emphasis on sustainability and a pressing need to mitigate climate change, the adoption of electric cars represents a significant step towards a greener future.

Beyond their environmental benefits, EVs are also disrupting traditional manufacturing processes, supply chains, and consumer preferences, ushering in a new era of mobility.

Zero emissions

The concept of ‘zero emissions’ is central to this transformation, emphasizing the absence of emissions in electric cars, particularly when powered by renewable energy sources.

This shift towards electric vehicles, characterized by zero tailpipe emissions, represents a significant step forward in reducing the automotive industry’s environmental impact, offering a cleaner, more sustainable alternative to gas-powered cars.

Electric vehicle batteries vs fossil fuel cars

Comparing the environmental impact between battery production for battery electric vehicles and emissions from conventional vehicles is complex and depends on several factors, including the manufacturing process of the batteries, the source of the energy used, often involving burning fossil fuels, the fuel efficiency of gas powered cars, and the lifecycle of both batteries and vehicles.

This comparison not only highlights the efficiency and potential of electric vehicles but also underlines the significant environmental advantages of electric vehicles over gas-powered cars, especially when considering the current state of the electric grid and its gradual shift towards more sustainable energy sources.

Environmental Effects of EV Batteries

The increased demand for electric vehicle batteries has raised questions about the environmental effects of EV batteries.

Although the manufacturing process involves emissions, research indicates that these initial emissions are offset by the long-term environmental benefits of electric cars.

Generally, battery production for electric vehicles has an initial climate impact due to the energy and materials required. This may include emissions from mining and refining metals such as lithium, nickel, and cobalt, as well as the energy used in the production process.

Recycling EV batteries presents a significant opportunity to reduce this environmental impact, as up to 95% of an EV battery can be recycled, thereby reducing the need for new materials and the emissions associated with making an EV.

Emissions Comparison

On the other hand, cars with fossil fuels generate continuous tailpipe emissions throughout their lifecycle, including during oil extraction and processing, refining, distribution, and fuel combustion. Electric vehicles, by contrast, have no tailpipe emissions, significantly reducing their greenhouse gas emissions when paired with a low-carbon electricity sector.

When comparing these two, several factors must be considered, including:

  1. Fuel efficiency: Electric vehicles are generally more energy-efficient than fossil fuel vehicles. While battery production for electric vehicles may have higher initial emissions, this can be offset by the lower emissions during the operational phase due to the absence of tailpipe emissions.
  2. Energy mix for electricity production: The climate impact of electric vehicles depends largely on the type of electricity generation used to charge them. If the electricity comes from low-carbon sources such as wind or solar power, the overall climate impact is lower.
  3. Lifecycle and recycling: The lifespan of both batteries and vehicles is crucial. If batteries and vehicles have long lifespans and can be efficiently recycled, the overall climate impact is reduced.

Technological advancements and improvements in EV’s battery manufacturing and sustainable energy production are expected to further reduce the climate impact associated with electric vehicles.

Emissions from Driving

On the other hand, emissions from fossil fuel cars, both during manufacturing and during operation, are significant contributors to climate change.

Both gasoline and diesel vehicles emit significant amounts of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases throughout their lifetime, contributing to global warming and deteriorating air quality. These emissions have been shown to have a harmful impact on the environment and human health over time.

In comparison, electric cars have been found to have significantly lower carbon dioxide emissions during their manufacturing process, meaning their environmental impact during production is less than that of gasoline and diesel vehicles during their lifespan with driving.

Additionally, electric vehicles typically are more energy-efficient and have lower emissions during operation, further reducing their long-term environmental impact compared to fossil-fueled vehicles. Thus, electric cars point towards a more sustainable and environmentally friendly future for transportation.

Conclusion

In conclusion, electric cars have a clear edge over traditional gasoline and diesel cars when it comes to long-term environmental benefits.

Despite worries about emissions from making batteries, studies reveal that electric cars are better for the environment due to fewer carbon emissions over their entire lifetime.

This highlights how electric cars not only help fight environmental change but also push the automotive industry toward more eco-friendly practices.

As more people embrace electric vehicles, we’re moving towards a greener future with clean energy for everyone.

 

Read more from Unimi

How long do electric car batteries last?

Advantages of EVs

16+Pays et en croissance

15000+installations et en croissance

50+modèles de chargeur supportés

Commandez via notre partenaire français STRADAL

Pour commander vos solutions Unimi en France, merci de contacter notre partenaire Stradal via le formulaire ou le numéro de téléphone.

Ce n’est pas tout

Pour toutes demandes ou questions, appelez M. Godou de Stradal : +33 (0)6 80 45 46 08